つづき
https://mathoverflow.net/questions/151286/probabilities-in-a-riddle-involving-axiom-of-choice
Probabilities in a riddle involving axiom of choice
asked Dec 9 '13 at 16:16 Denis
(Denis質問)
I think it is ok, because the only probability measure we need is uniform probability on {0,1,…,N?1}, but other people argue it's not ok, because we would need to define a measure on sequences, and moreover axiom of choice messes everything up.
(Pruss氏)
The probabilistic reasoning depends on a conglomerability assumption, ・・・and we have no reason to think that the conglomerability assumption is appropriate.
(Huynh氏)
If it were somehow possible to put a 'uniform' measure on the space of all outcomes, then indeed one could guess correctly with arbitrarily high precision, but such a measure doesn't exist.
mathoverflowは時枝類似で
・Denis質問でも、もともと”but other people argue it's not ok, because we would need to define a measure on sequences, and moreover axiom of choice messes everything up.”
Denisの経歴で、彼は欧州の研究所勤務で、other peopleは研究所の確率に詳しいらしい
・Pruss氏とHuynh氏とは、経歴を見ると、数学DRです。両者とも、このパズル(=riddle)は、可測性が保証されていないと回答しています
なお ”試しに"Alex Pruss Conglomerability"で検索した結果 Alexander Pruss本人のBlogが見つかった”スレ25 414-415
https://alexanderpruss.blogspot.com/2024/09/independence-conglomerability.html
Alexander Pruss's Blog September 11, 2024
Independence conglomerability
Conglomerability says that if you have an event E and a partition {Ri : i ∈ I} of the probability space, then if P(E∣Ri) ≥ λ for all i, we likewise have P(E) ≥ λ.
Conglomerabilityとは、ある事象Eと確率空間の分割{Ri:i∈I} があるとき、
すべてのi に対してP(E∣Ri) ≥λならば、同様にP(E) ≥λ が成り立つというものである。
Example: I am going to uniformly randomly choose a positive integer (using a countably infinite fair lottery, assuming for the sake of argument such is possible). For each positive integer n, you have a game available to you: the game is one you win if n is no less than the number I am going to pick. You despair: there is no way for you to have any chance to win, because whatever positive integer n you choose, I am infinitely more likely to get a number bigger than n than a number less than or equal to n, so the chance of you winning is zero or infinitesimal regardless which game you pick.
つづく
スレタイ箱入り無数目を語る部屋35(あほ二人の”アナグマの姿焼き"Part9w)
5132人目の素数さん
2026/09/21(月) 10:37:57.72ID:Urlt9ysyレスを投稿する
ニュース
- 【TBS】『VIVANT』映画化決定 12月4日公開 [Ailuropoda melanoleuca★]
- 【🍣】「夫婦2人で18万円の寿司」新宿区議の投稿…「申し訳ないとは思っていない」渡辺やすし氏 ★2 [少考さん★]
- 【コメ】倉庫には“古米の山” 販売店「かつてない量」 新米より古米が高い逆転現象… 赤字覚悟で販売 ★2 [ぐれ★]
- 高市総理⋯日朝会談実現に意欲 [少考さん★]
- 【国際】スペイン領カナリア諸島で移民急増、緊急事態宣言 政府に支援要請 [ぐれ★]
- 【芸能】女優・真木よう子 出産入院中に年下看護師から“理不尽な怒られ方” 妊娠糖尿病患い…就寝中に突然 [冬月記者★]
- 日本人の68%はラム肉を買ったことがないらしい 確かにマトンはよく買うけどラムは買った事ないわ [377482965]
- 「VIVANT」映画化決定、12月4日から全国で公開 [256556981]
- 月曜日前のメカコアラ軍曹ファンスレッド🐨🏡
- 俺の塩を食べなさい
- VIVANT映画化!w
- 元別班だけど質問ある?